"It's a little hard to program not knowing what's going on," Kristi Scott of Maui OnStage told The Maui News in September. She was talking about the county's plan to restore the roof of the Historic ʻĪao Theater on Market Street. "In order to do that, we'll have to shut down. We don't have a date, but we were told it would be within 2027."
The theater hasn't closed yet, but the schedule has already started moving. This month Maui OnStage is staging its youth show in Kihei and holding its "Raise the Roof" fundraiser in Kula. That leaves December as the time to see live theater in Wailuku Town on two stages: the 98-year-old ʻĪao, and the 200-seat black box MAPA opened on Main Street just a year ago.
What the county is replacing above 413 seats
The project is a full replacement, not a patch. The County of Maui's capital project sheet calls for complete removal, structural rehabilitation and replacement of the "deteriorated roof system," plus a rooftop photovoltaic system. The same documents list the reasons: extensive leaks and water damage, compromised trusses and beams, roofing materials beyond repair, and poor drainage and insulation in a building close to its centennial. The Maui News put the county's budget at about $3.8 million.
The original building cost a small fraction of that. According to the Maui OnStage history page, construction started in December 1927 for the Maui Amusement Company and cost $40,000. The Spanish Mission Revival theater opened on August 22, 1928, with Richard Dix in "Sporting Goods." So many people turned out that the manager added a second showing. It was built to seat 702 for movies and live shows. After later renovations it seats 413.
Concrete is the reason the building is still here. Wailuku had seven theaters back then. The ʻĪao was the last one built and is the only one still standing, which Maui OnStage credits to its mainly concrete construction. It's the third-oldest theater in Hawaii, after Honolulu's Hawaii Theatre from 1922 and Hilo's Palace Theater from 1925. It hosted USO shows during World War II. In 1953 it held the Hawaii premiere of "From Here to Eternity," with Frank Sinatra in the audience.
The county has owned the building since 1993, when it bought the theater and its one-acre site for $882,000. Its last major renovation, a $734,000 project, came the following year. Smaller upgrades followed over the next three decades, including air conditioning, seats, carpet, sound and lighting. The roof stayed on the to-do list. In its own timeline, Maui OnStage notes that the county approved funding in 2025 for roof repairs in 2027.
November's Maui OnStage dates are already outside Wailuku
The company that has called the ʻĪao home since 1984 is already working out what life looks like without it. Maui Community Theater moved in that year after an arson fire destroyed its old home, the Territorial Building at the old Kahului Fairgrounds.
Two November dates show where things are headed:
- "The Enchanted Bookshop," Nov. 14–22. This Maui OnStage youth production plays at ProArts Playhouse in Azeka Plaza Makai in Kihei, and tickets are sold through ProArts.
- "Raise the Roof" fundraiser, Saturday, Nov. 21, 5 to 8 p.m. It's at Ocean Organic Vodka Farm & Distillery in Kula. Tickets are $225 per person, or $234.07 with fees at checkout. The evening includes heavy pupus, craft cocktails, live entertainment, short performances and silent auctions. The event was first set for Sept. 26 before moving to the new date.
According to the Maui News, the Kula evening is a "sneak peek." Guests can guess the company's next season from clues hidden in the decorations and costumes, with season tickets going to the closest guess. Scott suggested construction wear or festive aloha attire, and the most creative look wins a door prize. Scott was direct about the cost of the closure. "We're having to come up with alternate venues," she told the paper. "It will be a loss of revenue for us because of rentals." Tickets are on Maui OnStage's event page.
The second stage on Main Street is selling out
The other half of Wailuku's December is new. MAPA, the Maui Academy of Performing Arts, built The Naylor, a black-box theater at 2027 Main Street, inside the former National Dollar Store building. The Maui News reported a maximum capacity of 200 seats when "Cabaret" opened the space in November 2025. The public grand opening came at Wailuku First Friday on April 3, 2026, with guided tours every 10 minutes and a look at rehearsals for "Frozen." The theater is named for philanthropist Susan Naylor, whose $1 million gift MAPA received during a capital campaign with a $15 million goal, as the Maui News reported in May 2025.
Even at less than half the ʻĪao's capacity, The Naylor is in demand. MAPA's run of "A Streetcar Named Desire" plays Nov. 20 through Dec. 6, with tickets listed from $17.50 to $45. Every listed performance is marked sold out on MAPA's ticketing page. If you already have seats, check the date. MAPA labels its Friday, Dec. 4 performance "FIRST FRIDAY IN WAILUKU" and recommends leaving extra time for traffic and parking that night.
Wailuku's stage calendar, mid-November through February
| Dates | Show | Where | Tickets |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov. 14–22 | "The Enchanted Bookshop," Maui OnStage youth production | ProArts Playhouse, Kihei | Through ProArts |
| Nov. 20–Dec. 6 | "A Streetcar Named Desire," MAPA | The Naylor, 2027 Main St. | $17.50–$45, listed as sold out |
| Nov. 21 | "Raise the Roof" fundraiser | Ocean Organic Vodka Farm & Distillery, Kula | $225 |
| Dec. 4 | First Friday performance of "Streetcar" | The Naylor | Part of the sold-out run |
| Dec. 12–20 | "Nutcracker Sweets," Maui OnStage | See mauionstage.com | Listed as "available SOON" |
| Dec. 14 | "December One Night Only," Maui OnStage | See mauionstage.com | Free series, seating "available SOON" |
| Feb. 5–21, 2027 | "The Last Five Years," MAPA | The Naylor | See mauiacademy.org |
| Feb. 14, 2027 | "An Afternoon with David Sedaris" | Facility rental through Maui OnStage | Ticketmaster |
The Dec. 14 date belongs to Maui OnStage's One Night Only series, which the company says "has been and always will be FREE to the public." Its general FAQ says the house opens at 6 p.m., the doors close at 6:30 p.m., and late arrivals are seated at the house manager's discretion. When seating for December's program opens, it will appear on mauionstage.com, alongside "Nutcracker Sweets." Scott told the Maui News the company is "good up through the end of this year."
Parking for a show night at the Wailuku Garage
Both theaters now point patrons to the same place. Maui OnStage's FAQ tells patrons the Wailuku Parking Garage is open, with the entrance on Church Street. According to Park Maui, the garage at 30 N. Church St. works like this:
- First floor is public. Upper floors are reserved for eligible resident and employee permit holders.
- Visitor rate is $1 an hour, capped at $10 a day.
- Residents get two free hours once a day with a Hawaiʻi driver's license, then pay $1 an hour. That covers most of a matinee.
- On First Friday nights, parking is free after 6 p.m. Use the Church Street entrance between Vineyard and Main, and keep in mind that Market Street closes to cars at 5:30 p.m. Anything still parked there after the closure can be ticketed and towed at the owner's expense.
- Leave the reserved stalls behind the ʻĪao alone. Maui OnStage says they belong to the Pono Building next door and cars parked there will be towed. Street parking is available on Market and Vineyard Streets.
That fourth rule matters most on Dec. 4. Wailuku First Friday came back on Nov. 6 after an October break for the Maui County Fair, with Nevah Too Late on the Market Street Stage and Get Up & Dance Maui and DJ Z down at the garage, Maui Now reported. A December evening with the street fair on Market and a sold-out show on Main means a lot of people looking for parking in the same few blocks.
What the calendar looks like once the roof comes off
The ʻĪao's 2027 calendar is already filling. Maui OnStage lists David Sedaris on Feb. 14, 2027, as a facility rental. Rentals are the revenue Scott said the company will lose while the stage is dark. The county's FY2027 proposed project sheet schedules roof activity from October 2026 through December 2027. Scott's own word on timing was "within 2027." On Main Street, MAPA has "The Last Five Years" booked at The Naylor for Feb. 5–21.
At Millennium Realty Inc., we're a family-led Makawao brokerage with Upcountry roots that go back to 1998, and we're glad the ʻĪao is getting the care it needs to make it to 100. If you have questions about life in Wailuku Town or anywhere else on Maui, Tracy Kalama and our team are happy to talk story. Contact Us.